gOS 1.01, the unofficial Google OS launched last week, is Ubuntu 7.10 with an idealistic twist. This lightweight ready-to-go operating system was built to be a desktop for the masses--something you could load onto an old machine for grandma and grandpa to surf the web and send email. According to the guys who assembled the distro, the purpose of their creation is to be a "simple, user friendly, beautiful desktop for normal people".
Unlike the complete distribution of its base OS, gOS doesn't come with many of the pre-loaded applications such as OpenOffice.org, The GIMP, or even Mozilla Thunderbird. Why? Because gOS's creators have gone in favour of web-based apps. Google apps to be precise. Which is obviously where its (unofficial) name comes from.
Downloading gOSLike Ubuntu, the OS is distributed as an ISO disk image that fits on a 700MB writable CD. The ISO is available via bit torrent and mine was a quick download with over 50 peers and 7 seeds. You can
grab yourself a copy here.
Installing gOSI didn’t burn mine onto a disc, instead I loaded the ISO onto a new virtual machine I made with VMware Fusion for the purpose of this review. Since the OS was suppose to be lightweight, all I gave this VM was access to 1 processor, 2GB of storage, and 256MB of memory. It worked quite well for a Linux Kernel 2.6.
I have to say that installing gOS was one of the easiest Linux installations ever. I didn’t do a count, but I felt it had less steps than installing Ubuntu and the only days of driver compatibility seem to be over.
The OS doesn’t allow you to install from the boot screen, rather it loads up the OS as a live CD and let’s you muck around with it first. If you like what you see, all you have to do is double click the “install” icon on the desktop and it begins writing files to storage.
You can see a
screen capture video of my installation here (42MB SWF).
First impressionsAs you can see from the screen shot above, this OS is really pretty and very Mac-like. Although gOS was built on Ubuntu, they’ve swapped out
Gnome for
Enlightenment. A good move if you ask me as it is more intuitive. My favourite usability feature is the “click anywhere” menu. You just left-click the desktop and the main menu pops up where your cursor is. Right-click and you get a list of applications. How much easier could that be?
Ethernet was automatically detected from my NAT virtual network connection, and every application from Firefox to Skype worked as it should except the Xine Movie player which crashed, but then again, I did only give the poor machine 256MB of memory.
It’s good that the network worked flawlessly because the OS would be rendered useless without a connection to the internet. Most of the “applications” on the dock exist only as web pages. It is a little unnerving for long-time computer users like myself to click on icons in the dock that launch nothing but a new tab in Firefox.
But I do get the gist of the project and appreciate the effort to integrate web apps into the desktop. The placing of Google search right on the desktop where Mac users normally find Spotlight is a really good strategic move towards the convergence.
The problemsBut not all things work right out of the box as they claim. For example, the direct link to YouTube from the dock is a bit silly as the distribution of Firefox doesn’t come with a Flash player plugin. Not sure if Adobe has let up, but there were no official Flash plugins the last I played with Linux. And no third-party hacks were in this distribution either.
It could be my virtual machine, although I see no reason why, but the filesystem crashed on me twice while trying to access the home folder. But I liked the recovery, it wasn’t a crash and die situation, but a quick and painless restart of the desktop. No apps were harmed in the process.
Does gOS hold potential?After playing with the OS for about two days, I have a couple of conclusions and questions on the future of such an OS. However much I love its ease of use, beautiful glossy interface, and lightweight distribution, I think it takes a lot more than just a face lift to make a desktop for the masses.
The biggest problem I see is web apps are not ready for the prime time. Think about this scenario: You pass grandma an Excel spreadsheet of the expenses table you worked out with her on a flash drive, she has to figure out how to upload that file into Google Spreadsheets before she can see what you’ve done. That compared to the Ubuntu 7.10 which comes ready with OpenOffice.org where a double click of the file is all it takes.
But the time is coming when
Google Gears,
Adobe AIR, and other web-to-desktop technologies take over these critical apps. But until then, this OS could easily exist as Firefox with a well stocked bookmarks bar.